I didn't misunderstand you at all. You have almost completely miunderstood my response if that's what you got from it.
And no, it's not a paradox. You can find a great deal by me on paradoxes on Medium. I know what paradoxes are and I know what contradictions are. You have stated a contradiction. Nothing can have value by not having value.
Bascially, you buy into the Romantic ideas on art. Yes, they are recent, and that matters a great deal. Kant was responding to art that had completely divorced itself from its roots in religion. There was an attempt…
Welcome! I’m so glad I am able to talk to you today about one of the most important things in the world: art. If you don’t think art is important, ask yourself how much time you spend listening to and telling stories, listening to music, playing songs, and enjoying movies. More likely than not, the answer is that you spend most of your day doing these things. If we spend so much time on the arts, then it must be important!
So, each of you is doing something very important: you are contributing to making the world a more…
“Virtue aims at the beautiful (to kalon).” — Aristotle
“Beauty is truth, truth beauty” — John Keats
The beautiful is fair, and the fair is just. — Elaine Scarry
We typically think of beauty, truth, virtue, and justice as being very different things. “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder” according to the common saying, which suggests that beauty is purely subjective. When we think of “truth,” we think of how something corresponds to reality. Virtue and justice both allow us to be maximally social, though virtue tends to be individual (you are brave or not) while justice involves…
I am the author of “Diaphysics” and “Hear the Screams of the Butterfly,” and a consultant, poet, playwright, and interdisciplinary scholar.